A&E’s new show “Heavy”
I don’t watch A&E much anymore, not since they became overrun with shows like Family Jewels and Dog the Bounty Hunter and sold their souls to be a 24/7 ad service for Big Pharma. But Heavy looked interesting. Take a bunch of morbidly obese individuals and introduce some major lifestyle changes. See what happens.
We watched the debut episode and while it was great to see the intense exercise regimen providing benefit to the two participants, they barely touched on diet. No details were provided as to their before/after meal plans. The show mostly focused on getting the participants moving, with lots of intense workout footage in a special treatment facility. From what little they did show about nutrition, it seems the show is following the calories-in/calories-out model, with the emphasis on caloric reduction and lean choices.
While people who are morbidly obese obviously need to improve their motor abilities, exercise is only about a third of the story. Up to two-thirds of their success (maybe more) will rely on diet, and this is where the show fails. I guess food is boring when you can show “action” footage of obese people barely walking a few feet or collapsing in a whimpering, sweaty mess. Doesn’t compare to shots of them sizzling a chicken breast or steaming some fresh veggies. Indeed, aside from a comment that Tom needed upwards of 10,000 calories daily just to survive and a quick trip to the lean meats counter at a grocery store, there was nothing, nada, zippo, about what these folks were being fed or how they were being educated about meal planning and preparation.
The other issue that bothered me was the slight implication that these individuals are obese by choice. They are weak, they are lazy, they do nothing but sit around and eat junk food, etc. I used to believe that, but after learning more about how insulin regulates fat tissue (and how diet regulates insulin), I’m more inclined to think that in many cases there is a metabolic disorder at work. Some people are more or less victims of a genetic predisposition to store and accumulate more fat while their bodies try to conserve energy. This leads to excessive cravings for sweet and sugary foods while the body signals them to be less active. The idea that their lifestyles could possibly be related to a regulatory disorder was never mentioned or explored. So less weeping women on treadmills, more scientific theories about how and why people become fat.
For people who might look to this show for guidance about their own weight situation, they might find inspiration in seeing some of the success stories. But they will find very little information about how to properly adjust their diets. Exercise is the primary focus of this show, and while it certainly has its benefits towards living a healthier lifestyle, it is really only a supplement to proper nutrition. Without the diet component being properly dialed in, exercise will yield little or no results.
By choosing to focus on only one aspect of weight loss, Heavy seems to be just another reality show designed more for high drama and emotional exploitation than an informative and inspirational approach to sustained and manageable weight loss. I applaud the participants for trying to change their lives for the better and I might watch a few more episodes to see if the format improves. But for now the show was an overall disappointment.



